Voters 55
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
M
- + 49 voters
-
A
-
C
-
K
-
A
-
M
-
E
-
M
-
-
-
M
-
V
-
-
-
B
-
D
-
D
-
-
V
-
S
-
S
-
A
-
G
-
J
-
L
-
B
-
A
-
-
J
-
Y
-
-
D
-
-
-
M
-
-
-
Z
-
?
-
-
-
N
-
-
-
C
-
-
-
-
55
Website detects new deposits/trades as profits
- Under review
- Subscribe
|
S |
Shannak Bro |
The website shouldn't calculate new trades or deposits as profit, I deposited some money and entered a new 3x margin trade and the website detects it as 600% profit in the last 24 hours. This is wrong.
Activity Newest / Oldest
vcoronel127
This is definitely screwing with my portfolio profit/loss data. It's so sad that such a basic feature isn't yet available and we've been requesting this for years now.
Aram Muradyan
Merged with: USD deposit/withdrawal shouldnt count as profit/loss
Andrew Chouman
I deposit and withdraw from my wallet in USD and it counts as profit/loss. Can there be an option to not count that so it doesnt skew my actual profit margins?
Aram Muradyan
Merged with: Transfers shouldn't be included in P&L
Jroon
This is a BIG ONE>
If I transfer some btc off exchange from coinbase pro to coinbase, it shouldn't be included in P&L.
The amount of coins in my possession hasn't changed, neither should my P&L.
Will Glaeser
Right now, if I deposit $1000 to Coinbase (for example), the app will count that as a $1000 gain. It is not a gain! This problem is making the app useless for tracking true performance of assets. Please fix the issue and then this will be the best portfolio tracking app out there!
Aram Muradyan
Status changed to: Under review
Annette Donofrio
Really unfortunate to see this issue reported by others 2 years ago and still present. Might have to find another portfolio manager is this is a deal breaker.
Annette Donofrio
Hugely problematic. Also happening to/from Ledger cold wallet transfers which are tracking as if assets were sold/bought between transfers showing erroneous P&L.
Guilherme Teixeira
Totally agree ... That's just a change in volume not P&L. Please check that asap, or at least as an option...for any coin of course.
Will Glaeser
Can't believe this still hasn't been addressed.
bigshooTer39
How do I get around this? I'd like to manually change the tagging of the transactions but I'm not able to edit the transactions from an API
Kyrian
+++
Please add this!
Delta APP had this feature and it's an absolute must to keep track of PnL
Cam
Agree!! I've just come across this one when I noticed my P&L is all messed up. I transferred a token from my Exodus Wallet to Binance and it has reset the Current Holdings P/L so now I have no idea of that coin is in profit or loss. Both wallets are on CoinsStats, so this needs to be handled. Koinly is able to connect this as a transfer. What a mess!
Will Glaeser
Yes this makes the app basically useless and I am surprised they haven't fixed this or commented on it.
Will Glaeser
This is the sole problem keeping me from paying for CoinStats. If they fix this, I will happily pay for it and recommend it to everyone I know. Until then, I am actively looking for an alternative.
Alan Vu
Yes! Any transfers from Coinbase to my crypto wallet also counts as P/L. Please address this, CoinStats team.
Andy
That would be a deal breaker!
mohamed Abdelmottaleb
This is an important request. Withdrawal inclusion in PNL calculation is disastrous. Especially while using multiple exchanges and moving cash between them
Crypto Lystic
I agree
Kiel Pataky
Additionally, transactions on uni swap end up showing as transfers , which really is a sell item. So it’s throwing off the numbers. Overall great app. I use to use delta pro. Now I use you!